Key West Style Homes For Sale in Sarasota

All Listings $100,000 - $200,000 $200,000 - $300,000
$300,000 - $400,000 $400,000 - $500,000 $500,000 - $600,000
$600,000 - $700,000 $700,000 - $800,000 $800,000 - $900,000
$900,000 - $1,000,000 Over $1,000,000

Market Statistics

Total Listings: 173
Average Price: $1,418,984
Highest Price: $6,900,000
Lowest Price: $199,900

Key West Style Homes For Sale in Sarasota - Page #2

173 Properties Found. Page 2 of 5.
Photo of Listing #A4420800

Welcome to Stock Signature Homes Margo II Furnished Model! This luxurious home is in the magnificent fully gated village of The Lake Club in Lakewood Ranch. This home has been beautifully appointed...

Photo of Listing #A4448405

Stunning views of the Intracoastal and private deeded beach access across the street provides this home with an idyllic island setting. One level of living with features that many buyers seek inclu...

Photo of Listing #A4440329

BRAND NEW! This well aquainted, turn-key furnished home is conveniently situated in the heart of Holmes Beach. Just steps from the beach and a short walk or bike ride from Anna Maria's exquisite di...

Photo of Listing #A4406797

This Island gem has been lovingly remodeled to preserve the original character of this Anna Maria home. Designer details abound both inside and out. The tropical pool and spa feature a theme park ...

Photo of Listing #A4402654

"Pineapple Paradise" is an exceptional AMI coastal cottage located in the 200 block of 65th Street! New in 2016 this beauty was professionally decorated and boasts Du-chateau hardwood floors, custo...

Photo of Listing #D6107571

MANASOTA KEY FULL GULF VIEWS! A TOTAL FAMILY RETREAT OR INVESTOR ISLAND INCOME PROPERTY. Long rental history. Enormous views of the Gulf of Mexico. Nestled by natures landscape and a winding drive ...

Photo of Listing #A4407687

"Sign of the Mermaid" is a BRAND NEW beach house built in 2018 and is located WEST of Gulf Drive in the City of Anna Maria and just four houses to the beach without having to cross any major roads!...

Photo of Listing #A4435492

Welcome to Stock Signature Homes Glenmore Furnished Model! This luxurious home is in the magnificent fully gated village of The Lake Club in Lakewood Ranch. This home has been beautifully appointe...

Photo of Listing #A4436163

Under Construction. BRAND NEW CONSTRUCTION ON ANNA MARIA ISLAND HAS GREAT FEATURES INSIDE AND OUT. THIS CUSTOM BUILT HOME HAS 4 BEDS, 4.5 BATHS, CUSTOM TILE AND CUSTOM TRIM PACKAGE THROUGHOUT. TH...

Photo of Listing #A4445676

Seller has priced aggressively at LAND VALUE for immediate sale. Located in Oyster Bay, one of Sarasota’s most revered neighborhoods and close to the Field Club. Located on a quiet cul-de-sac stre...

Photo of Listing #A4214342

Fabulous new construction 5-bedroom coastal home with 4 baths is located on the highly desirable northern end of Anna Maria Island. The home has upscale finishes and an amazing floor plan with op...

Photo of Listing #A4438678

Located just 1 block to Anna Maria Island's landmark Bean Point, beach access and the azure waters of the Gulf of Mexico. This fabulous 2016 home, fully furnished for the casual lifestyle, is the p...

Photo of Listing #A4210381

Custom built home located just a short walk to the beach on Anna Maria Island. This home has tons of unique high end finishes throughout. This large single family home has wood grain tile, high va...

Photo of Listing #A4444576

The Peninsula Estate: Enjoy the Good Life with sweeping panoramic water views from every room, while enjoying hypnotic sunrises and sunsets while dolphins and manatees play just a few feet away. Bo...

Photo of Listing #A4430933

REMINISCENT OF THE WEST INDIES, THIS PRISTINE NEWER (BUILT IN 2016), OPEN LIVING CONCEPT, OFFERS THE HIGHEST STANDARDS OF MIAMI DADE HURRICANE CONSTRUCTION, INCLUDING IMPACT WINDOWS; & DESIGNED FOR...

Photo of Listing #A4435225

Imagine coming home to marvelous views of Tampa Bay and then walking a few steps to famous Pine Avenue for fabulous shopping and great restaurants for fresh seafood and craft cocktails. Here is a w...

Photo of Listing #A4450069

If you are looking for Coastal style with a modern twist, you have found it. Built by Najjar Construction, this light and bright 3 bedroom (WITH OPTIONAL 4TH BEDROOM)/4 bath SOUTHERN EXPOSED pool h...

Photo of Listing #A4432864

NEWLY CONSTRUCTED HOME ON BEAUTIFUL ANNA MARIA ISLAND, IS A BLOCK TO THE BEACH AND 2 BLOCKS TO THE BAY. THIS HOME HAS 6 BEDROOMS 4 FULL AND 2 HALF BATHS, AND AN EXTRA BONUS DEN AREA. INSIDE THE H...

Photo of Listing #A4438072

Nestled off the beaten path on south Siesta Key lays this exclusive private residence directly on the beach with water on both sides. Rest your boat on the lift in the backyard while you enjoy your...

Photo of Listing #A4451616

LOCATION BEYOND COMPARE Discover this amazing bayfront location on secluded Casey Key with panoramic views, private deeded beach access, excellent boating & fishing close to the inlet to the Gulf. ...

Photo of Listing #A4187388

New, now open. John Cannon Homes presents The Milina model in Legacy Estates at Esplanade on Palmer Ranch. The Milina model is home to exquisite design details, finishes and furnishings and is avai...

Photo of Listing #A4452213

Stunning and beautifully appointed island home, just a short stroll away from the lovely sunsets on Anna Maria Island. This home features a lovely coastal decor , barn door, vaulted ceilings, open...

Photo of Listing #A4438985

Island living at its finest! Beautifully decorated and maintained home, with recent updates. Less than 1 block from the Gulf beaches of Anna Maria Island, this property boasts a tropical oasis styl...

Photo of Listing #A4439659

What a view!! Take in the endless water views from the multiple elevated decks, including a 360 view of the Intracoastal Waterway to the Gulf Of Mexico, from the rooftop deck! This new home, built ...

Photo of Listing #A4415695

In harmony with nature, sitting on 0.48 acres of land and a cul de sac, this unique and grand Key West style home brings alive the charm of modern coastal living and the enjoyment of your own PRIVA...

Photo of Listing #A4446899

Pre-Construction. To be built. Water’s Edge at Sanctuary Cove - Manatee County’s newest Waterfront Boating Community on the Manatee River! Nutter Custom Construction's Windward model has a true Wes...

Photo of Listing #A4433741

Pre-Construction. To be built. The beach and beautiful sunsets? Or a round of golf along the Gulf? How about both. Or maybe shopping the posh St. Armand’s Circle is more your style. Whatever your d...

Photo of Listing #A4441501

Built in 2018, and a winner in the Parade of Homes, this Custom Waterfront Home has countless upgrades! Costal designed 3 Bedroom, 2 1/2 Bath, 2 Car Garage home is steps from Hidden Harbor Marina ...

Photo of Listing #A4436175

NEWER ELEVATED HOME HAS EVERYTHING YOU COULD WANT IN A BEACH HOME. IT HAS 5 BEDS AND 3.5 BATHS, LARGE GREAT ROOM, AND A BIG MASTER SUITE. IT ALSO HAS SOLID GRANITE SURFACES, SOLID WOOD CABINETS, ...

Photo of Listing #N6108005

A Rare Find! Stunning expansive Water Views of Roberts Bay with 120 feet of water frontage! Gorgeous Key West Floridian home that has numerous upgrades with the current remodeling renovations. The ...

Photo of Listing #A4204906

JUST COMPLETED IN 2016 THIS NEWER STYLE BEACH HOUSE IS ONLY A SHORT WALK TO THE BEACH. IT HAS HIGH END FINISHES INCLUDING SOLID WOOD CABINETS, SOLID GRANITE SURFACES, VAULTED CEILINGS, LED LIGHTIN...

Photo of Listing #A4205423

Move-In Ready - The Bermuda by Heritage Builders is ideally situated on the largest home site in West Bay, a private gated enclave of only 4 luxury single family residences in Sarasota's most sough...

Photo of Listing #O5778876

BEAUTIFUL remodeled (2011) single family SARASOTA BAYFRONT home. One small block to the the world's most beautiful beaches for amazing sunsets. Granite kitchen with stainless steel appliances. The...

Photo of Listing #A4447513

Fun and tastefully decorated, “Coastal Breeze” is the ideal home for an Anna Maria Island family retreat or investment property with it's high rental income (approximately $125K annually). Situated...

Photo of Listing #A4438517

Are you ready for effortless island life? This absolutely one-of-a-kind property is the perfect balance of casual, relaxed style and serious sophistication. You’ll revel in the breezy feel and luxe...

Photo of Listing #A4452376

This custom-built, island-inspired home is located in a premier gated boating community on a prime lot that captures the true essence of Florida living. Upon entering you will be mesmerized by the ...

All listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified through personal inspection by appropriate professionals. Listings displayed on this website may be subject to prior sale or removal from sale; availability of any listing should always be independently verified.

Listing information is provided for consumer personal, non-commercial use, solely to identify potential properties for potential purchase; all other use is strictly prohibited and may violate relevant federal and state law.

Listing data comes from My Florida Regional MLS DBA Stellar MLS.

Listing information last updated on December 10th, 2019 at 12:00am EST.