Casey Key Real Estate

Casey Key real estate

The picturesque Casey Key is one of Florida's best kept secret gems. It is unadorned by tourists standards, but its the perfect island for those that want to get away from it all. The barrier island also allows the Casey Key home buyers to get back to basics and enjoy a touch of Old Florida and the natural beauty many residents within the state have come to love. 

Casey Key is a short 8-miles of breathtaking shoreline, white sandy beaches and subtropical properties. The area offers welcomed seclusion from cluttered commercial cities, and it is less than 300 yards at its largest West to East width. At the North end of Casey Key is Sarasota Bay's Siesta Key area. However, Casey Key extends into the Venice Beach area on its South end. The Gulf of Mexico flanks the area on its west side, while Casey Key's East side is covered by Little Sarasota Bay, Dryman Bay and Black Burn Bay. Read more about Casey Key real estate.

Casey Key Homes For Sale

All Listings $600,000 - $700,000 $700,000 - $800,000
$800,000 - $900,000 Over $1,000,000
Sort by:
View Results by:

No listings were found that matched this criteria.

4024 Casey Key Rd, Nokomis $1,950,000

  • 4 Beds
  • 4.0 Baths
  • 4,081 SqFt
  • 0.40 Acres

Breathtaking 180 ° View Of Little Sarasota Bay And The Intracoastal. Paradise Found! Just Beyond The Historic Blackburn Point Swing Bridge This Gorgeous Casey Key Estate Awaits You! Deeded Beach Access Across The Street. Boathouse For Jet Skis Or Kayaks And...

Listings have been deleted from all results. Undo Last Delete or View All Deleted Listings

420 Casey Key Rd, Nokomis $879,900

  • 3 Beds
  • 3.0 Baths
  • 5,501 SqFt
  • 0.49 Acres

Main House Built In 1985 And A Guest Cottage Built In 1947 Are On The Property. Wonderful Bay Views And Great Boating Water To Dock The Larger Yacht. Value Is In The Land. This Property Is Being Sold As/is With Right To Inspect. All Utilities Are Off And It...

Listings have been deleted from all results. Undo Last Delete or View All Deleted Listings

507 Casey Key Rd, Nokomis $5,945,000

  • 5 Beds
  • 7.0 Baths
  • 6,861 SqFt
  • 0.72 Acres

Refined Elegance In A Near-perfect Location, This 2008-built Casey Key Gulf-front Estate Has It All. Upon Entering Though The Custom Double Doors, One Is Greeted By The Grand Curved Staircase And Dramatic Two-story Living Room That Gives Way To Breathtaking...

Listings have been deleted from all results. Undo Last Delete or View All Deleted Listings

1300 Casey Key Rd, Nokomis $3,900,000

  • 3 Beds
  • 2.0 Baths
  • 2,170 SqFt
  • 1.14 Acres

Perfectly Poised At Midkey On The Desirable Island Of Casey Key, This 1.14-acre Gulf-to-bay Lot Offers Exceptional Depth Affording Many Building Options. With Underground Utilities, Direct Panoramic Views Of The Gulf Of Mexico To The West And Expansive Vist...

Listings have been deleted from all results. Undo Last Delete or View All Deleted Listings

420 N Casey Key Rd, Osprey $4,750,000

  • 4 Beds
  • 8.0 Baths
  • 5,836 SqFt
  • 0.55 Acres

Prepare To Say “wow” Upon Entering “jasmine By The Bay,” A Custom Bayfront Residence On Coveted North Casey Key, Built In 2005-2006 By Noted Builder, The Island Building Company. Designed With Ease Of Living In Mind And Loaded With Charm And Character Of Co...

Listings have been deleted from all results. Undo Last Delete or View All Deleted Listings

940 N Casey Key Rd, Osprey $3,499,000

  • 3 Beds
  • 2.0 Baths
  • 2,418 SqFt
  • 0.90 Acres

Paradise Found! Rare Opportunity. Only Two Families Have Owned This Secluded Oak Canopied Estate In The Past 60 Years. Private, Very, Very Private. Truly Exclusive Gulf To Bay Nearly One Acre Masterpiece With Your Own Personal Beach. Located On One Of The M...

Listings have been deleted from all results. Undo Last Delete or View All Deleted Listings

3807 Casey Key Rd, Nokomis $2,100,000

  • 0.42 Acres

Enjoy Long Walks On The Beach, The Gentle Gulf Of Mexico Waters And Near-perfect Sunsets From Your New Home On This Spectacular Casey Key Gulf-front Lot. With 100 Feet Of Water Frontage And An Incredible Location, The Opportunity To Build Your Dream Waterfr...

Listings have been deleted from all results. Undo Last Delete or View All Deleted Listings

402 N Casey Key, Osprey $1,995,000

  • 0.86 Acres

Quite Possibly The Area's Most Enticing And Captivating Bay Front Property With Close To 1 Acre Of Cleared Land And 200 Ft. Of Spectacular Bay Frontage At One Of The Island's Highest Elevations. Site Has Dock In Place With Great Boating Water Plus The Deede...

Listings have been deleted from all results. Undo Last Delete or View All Deleted Listings

2116 Casey Key Rd, Nokomis $4,850,000

  • 3 Beds
  • 4.0 Baths
  • 5,590 SqFt
  • 0.77 Acres

The Villa Sul Mare Estate On The Island Of Casey Key On The Southwest Coast Of Florida South Of Sarasota Boasts Sweeping Views Of Little Sarasota Bay And The Gulf Of Mexico. On The Bay Side Of The Property, The Dock And Boat Lift Offer Easy Access To Deep W...

Listings have been deleted from all results. Undo Last Delete or View All Deleted Listings

410 N Casey Key Rd, Osprey $1,950,000

  • 3 Beds
  • 3.0 Baths
  • 2,006 SqFt
  • 0.65 Acres

This Magnificent Home With 100 Feet Of Direct Bay Front Occupies Nearly Three Quarter Of Lushly Landscaped Acres On The Highly Private Coveted North End Of Casey Key. Embellished With A Host Of Lustrous Finishes And Elegant Features, This Bay Front Residenc...

Listings have been deleted from all results. Undo Last Delete or View All Deleted Listings

1232 N Casey Key Rd, Osprey $7,500,000

  • 4 Beds
  • 6.0 Baths
  • 8,121 SqFt
  • 1.18 Acres

The Luxuries Adorning Every Aspect Of This Four Bedroom Gulf-to-bay Estate Will Astound You. Designed By Architect Randall Paul Sample And Built To The Highest Standards By Westwater Construction, This Tuscan-inspired Home Rests On More Than One-acre Of Pro...

Listings have been deleted from all results. Undo Last Delete or View All Deleted Listings

Reviews for Casey Key Real Estate

5 Based on 1 Rating
View all Community Ratings & Reviews

Recent Ratings & Reviews

, Visitor





Simply stunning. Casey Key is one of the nicest places you will find in Florida. I don't live on the island but my brother does and he lets me use his house. The beaches are to die for!

Your Rating *

How Do You Know?

Live/Lived Here Just Visited

About You

*Your email address will not be displayed

Your Review



Five Things You Should Know about Casey Key Homes

 Casey Key has the largest concentration of beach homes in the Sarasota area.

 Casey Key real estate is not an option if you desire condominium living.

 Want boating and beach? Casey Key offers the most gulf to bay estates than other Sarasota islands.

 Want Privacy? The island is more secluded than Bird Key, Longboat Key, Lido Key and Siesta Key.

  Stephen King owns a house here. John Gottie once owned a large beachfront estate on Casey Key.


Casey Key Homes For Sale

Casey Key Homes For Sale

Casey Key real estate provides a rare opportunity to own a piece of unparalleled Florida property. The area affords the opportunity to live within a spectacularly designed million dollar estate or vacation home that has access to both bay and gulf activities that are just steps away from each other.

These waterfront Casey Key homes and bay view homes offer spectacular architecture, such as Old Florida, Modern, Key West and Spanish-Mediterranean Villas. Today, the area is home to less than 600 residents, but Casey Key real estate is extremely limited. For this reason, many have already taken advantage of the stunning homes the area provides, including 3-bedroom homes, 4-bedroom homes, 5-bedroom Casey Key homes and up.

These compounds and estates are spacious and offer dynamic floor plans and immaculate outdoor designs that often include private boardwalks, on-ground tennis courts, swimming pools. Homebuyers will find compounds with expanded living space that ranges from 1,400 square feet to nearly 14,000 square feet.

Some Casey Key homes offer serene and lush landscapes with mature foliage, while others may be surrounded by Oak trees with subtropical landscapes or hardscapes. With private beach or bay access, walled and gated single family homes and exquisite living areas, its no wonder that many have already chosen to live the ultimate Casey Key real estate lifestyle.

Map of Casey Key


Living on Casey Key

Casey Key HomesWhen biking or driving within the community of Casey Key visitors will notice the collection of newer million dollar homes, villas, estates and family vacation homes that peek out from behind the Palm trees, Pine trees and other subtropical foliage that adorns the area. Of course, Casey Key real estate includes some older beach homes, a few hotels and even fewer non-highrise condos nestled within the area. The community is safe from any mass commercial development, because of the area's restrictive covenants.

Even so, Casey Key homes are situated on either side of the only passage way within the area, Casey Key Road. Residents and Florida visitors gain driving access to the area via two connecting bridges. The Southern bridge is located at Albee Road West, while the Northern bridge is located at Blackburn Point Road.

Because of the exclusive nature of the beach, there is limited access to public services on the island. Most residents will need to head to venice or Sarasota, Florida for public services they need.

Yet, residents and visitors often head to Nokomis Beach to take advantage of the public facilities that are available within Casey Key. This long stretch of beach is a hot spot for locals that enjoy sunbathing, walks along the gently sloping barrier, and the charming tiki snack bars just off the white sandy shore. Nokomis beach also offers access to a breathtaking boardwalk and exclusive boat launch area.

Can't find what you're looking for? Let me do the work for you. Fill out the form below and a detailed description of the type of property you're interested in and I'll send you everything currently available.

Your Contact Information

Please provide a valid email address.

Property Information

Moving Details


Top of Page

All listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified through personal inspection by appropriate professionals. Listings displayed on this website may be subject to prior sale or removal from sale; availability of any listing should always be independently verified.

Listing information is provided for consumer personal, non-commercial use, solely to identify potential properties for potential purchase; all other use is strictly prohibited and may violate relevant federal and state law.

Listing data comes from My Florida Regional MLS.

Listing information last updated on February 8th, 2016 at 3:25pm EST.