Casey Key Homes For Sale - Sarasota

Casey Key real estateFind the newest Casey Key homes & real estate for sale in Sarasota County, Florida below! The community of Casey Key is one of Florida's best kept secret gems. It is unadorned by tourists' standards, but its the perfect island for those living here that want real estate away from it all. The barrier island also allows the Casey Key home buyers to get back to basics and enjoy a touch of Old Florida and the natural beauty many residents within the state have come to love.

Casey Key is a short 8-miles of breathtaking shoreline, white sandy beaches and subtropical properties. The area offers welcomed seclusion from cluttered commercial cities, and it is less than 300 yards at its largest West to East width. At the North end of Casey Key is Sarasota Bay's Siesta Key area. However, Casey Key extends into the Venice Beach area on its South end. The Gulf of Mexico flanks the area on its west side, while Casey Key's East side is covered by Little Sarasota Bay, Dryman Bay and Black Burn Bay. For information about Casey Key neighborhood properties for sale or to schedule a private home showing, contact your Sarasota County FL DWELL real estate experts today!

Real Estate For Sale Casey Key Sarasota

All Listings $400,000 - $500,000 $800,000 - $900,000
$900,000 - $1,000,000 Over $1,000,000

Real Estate For Sale Casey Key Sarasota

30 Properties Found. Page 1 of 1.
Photo of Listing #G5006364
Photo of Listing #A4410836
Photo of Listing #A4408555
Photo of Listing #N6101230
Photo of Listing #A4408082
Photo of Listing #A4407245
Photo of Listing #A4404789
Photo of Listing #A4404840
Photo of Listing #A4400942
Photo of Listing #U8001075
Photo of Listing #A4413722
Photo of Listing #U8016163
Photo of Listing #A4214651
Photo of Listing #R4707520
Photo of Listing #A4208659
Photo of Listing #A4207350
Photo of Listing #A4207422
Photo of Listing #N6100284
Photo of Listing #A4203910
Photo of Listing #A4203031
Photo of Listing #A4202455
Photo of Listing #N5915098
Photo of Listing #A4201020
Photo of Listing #A4198478
Photo of Listing #N5913345
Photo of Listing #A4185393
Photo of Listing #A4177105
Photo of Listing #A4197366
Photo of Listing #A4190275
Photo of Listing #A4127758

Search All Real Estate Listings in: Sarasota
See TODAY's New Listings, search by beds/baths, home & lot size, listing status, days on market & more!

Selling or buying a home in Casey Key soon? Call DWELL Real Estate (941) 822-0708, your Sarasota County, Florida real estate team. Our community of local Casey Key real estate agents will help you navigate the housing market in Casey Key Sarasota County, FL.

Casey Key Real Estate Market

The Casey Key real estate market provides a rare opportunity to own a piece of unparalleled Florida property. The community gives residents the options of living in a million dollar estate or vacation home on property that has access to both bay and gulf activities that are just steps away from each other.

These waterfront and bay view homes in Casey Key offer spectacular architecture options as well, such as Old Florida, Modern, Key West and Spanish-Mediterranean Villas. Today, this community is home to less than 600 residents living here, making Casey Key real estate extremely limited. Buyers touring the area will find 3-5 bedroom homes with floor plans that range from 1,400 to 14,000 sq ft of living space. These estates are spacious and offer dynamic floor plans and immaculate outdoor designs that often include private boardwalks, on-ground tennis courts, swimming pools.

Some Casey Key homes for sale offer serene and lush landscapes with mature foliage, while others may be surrounded by Oak trees with subtropical landscapes or hardscapes. With private beach or bay access and exquisite living areas, its no wonder that many have already chosen to purchase Casey Key real estate as their forever home.

Casey Key Videos

Five Things You Should Know about Casey Key Homes

 Casey Key has the largest concentration of beach homes in the Sarasota area.

 Casey Key real estate is not an option for buyers who desire condominium living.

 Casey Key offers the most gulf to bay estates than other Sarasota islands.

 The island is more secluded than Bird Key, Longboat Key, Lido Key and Siesta Key.

  Stephen King owns a house here. John Gottie once owned a large beachfront estate on Casey Key.


Living on Casey Key


Casey Key HomesWhen biking or driving within the community of Casey Key visitors will notice the collection of newer million dollar homes, villas, estates and family vacation homes that peek out from behind the Palm trees, Pine trees and other subtropical foliage that adorns the area. Of course, Casey Key real estate includes some older beach homes for sale, a few hotels and even fewer non-highrise condo properties nestled within the area. The community is protected from any mass commercial development, because of the area's restrictive covenants.

Even so, Casey Key houses are situated on either side of the only passage way within the area, Casey Key Road. Residents living here and Florida visitors gain driving access to the area via two connecting bridges. The Southern bridge is located at Albee Road West, while the Northern bridge is located at Blackburn Point Road.

Because of the amount of private property around this beach, there is limited access to public services on the island. Most residents will need to head to venice or Sarasota, Florida for public services they need.

Yet, residents and visitors often head to Nokomis Beach to take advantage of the public facilities that are available within Casey Key. This long stretch of beach is a hot spot for locals that enjoy sunbathing, walks along the barrier, and the charming tiki snack bars just off the shore. Nokomis beach also offers access to a breathtaking boardwalk and exclusive boat launch area.

Map of Casey Key


Casey Key Community Highlights

  • This neighborhood is home to just under 500 residents featuring a mix of modest beach bungalows as well as waterfront mansions
  • With the island being so narrow, most homeowners also own the property that’s on both the gulf and bay sides of the home
  • Popular attractions include crossing the Blackburn Point bridge to the Casey Key Tiki Bar and the Casey Key Fish House
  • Major medical facilities to serve the area are Sarasota Memorial Hospital, Venice Regional Bayfront Health and the Care Center at Venice

Casey Key Real Estate Agents

Planning to buy or sell a home in Casey Key? Let our local Casey Key real estate team guide you through the sale of your current Casey Key home or purchase your next Casey Key property. As Casey Key real estate agents and experts, we're well-versed in the unique market dynamics of Casey Key real estate. We're ready to work with you today!

Contact DWELL Real Estate to learn more about representation for buyers and sellers. Preparing to sell your Casey Key home? View our comparative market analysis page to receive a free Casey Key home value estimate analysis within moments.

Contact Information
Please provide a valid email address.
Mailing Address
Property Information
Moving Details


Top of Page

All listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified through personal inspection by appropriate professionals. Listings displayed on this website may be subject to prior sale or removal from sale; availability of any listing should always be independently verified.

Listing information is provided for consumer personal, non-commercial use, solely to identify potential properties for potential purchase; all other use is strictly prohibited and may violate relevant federal and state law.

Listing data comes from My Florida Regional MLS.

Listing information last updated on September 19th, 2018 at 11:30am EDT.