Bay Island on Siesta Key, Florida

Bay Island Siesta Key

Search Bay Island homes & real estate for sale in Siesta Key, FL below! Bay Island is made up of 169 single family homes. Most of the bay front homes sell in the multi-millions. There have been sales in excess of $5 million. Non waterfront homes start in the $300,000's. Take a look at the homes for sale below.

Siesta Key, a beautiful 8-mile long barrier island visited by tourists from all across the globe and home to some 24,000 residents, was founded in 1846. Today, Siesta Key is regarded as a tropical paradise, attracting guests for its fine white sand reputed to be one of the finest and whitest in the world. The average annual temperature in the Siesta Key is 75 degrees, providing a good winter vacation getaway for some families. Commercial complexes and modern facilities provide endless entertainment, shopping, and dining for visitors as well as residents. For more information about Bay Island neighborhood properties for sale or to schedule a home tour showing, call your Siesta Key, Florida DWELL real estate experts now!

Sold Bay Island Homes

Bay Island Homes For Sale

All Listings Under $100,000 $600,000 - $700,000
$700,000 - $800,000 Over $1,000,000
Sort by:
View Results by:

No listings were found that matched this criteria.

3810 Flamingo Ave, Sarasota $2,249,000

  • 4 Beds
  • 5.0 Baths
  • 3,960 SqFt
  • 0.26 Acres

Fantastic Custom Key West Style Residence Poised On One Of The Finest North End Siesta Key Streets, Flamingo Avenue, In Exclusive Bay Island The Gateway To Siesta Key With Quick On And Off Island Access. Sophisticated Yet Casual Home On Deepwater Hanson Bay...

Listings have been deleted from all results. Undo Last Delete or View All Deleted Listings

3435 Seagrape Dr, Sarasota $6,000

  • 4 Beds
  • 3.0 Baths
  • 2,800 SqFt
  • 0.48 Acres

Privacy, Location And Convenience In The Great Neighborhood Of Bay Island. A Vintage Home Built In 1934. Designed In The Monterey Style Which Was Popularized By The Hollywood Elite In The Early 1900's. Situated Off The Main Road And Is Entirely Surrounded A...

Listings have been deleted from all results. Undo Last Delete or View All Deleted Listings

617 Siesta Dr, Sarasota $700,000

  • 5 Beds
  • 4.0 Baths
  • 2,709 SqFt
  • 0.30 Acres

Siesta Key's Starfish Cottage: Welcome, Ocean Lovers & Beachcombers To The Coveted North End Of Siesta Key; Where The Gorgeous White Sands Of Shell Beach Are Just A Few Blocks Away. For The Savvy Buyer Seeking The Laid Back Island Lifestyle This Enchanted C...

Listings have been deleted from all results. Undo Last Delete or View All Deleted Listings

625 Freeling Dr, Sarasota $2,950,000

  • 4 Beds
  • 5.0 Baths
  • 5,036 SqFt
  • 0.76 Acres

This Italian Inspired Estate, Set On ¾ Acre Of Selby Garden-inspired Grounds, Recalls A Time Of Relaxed Sophistication & Cherished Privacy. This Is An Opportunity To Own A Piece Of Sarasota Art History On Siesta Key’s Bay Island. The Property Was Formerly O...

Listings have been deleted from all results. Undo Last Delete or View All Deleted Listings

852 Freeling Dr, Sarasota $2,950,000

  • 4 Beds
  • 5.0 Baths
  • 4,202 SqFt
  • 0.31 Acres

Stunning Bayfront On One Of Sarasota’s Most Desirable Streets: This Freeling Drive Home Offers Long Views Of The Bay And Bird Islands While Accommodating The Most Demanding Boater With Very Deep Private Dockage, Power Hoist And Immediate Access To The Gulf...

Listings have been deleted from all results. Undo Last Delete or View All Deleted Listings

826 Norsota Way, Sarasota $2,395,000

  • 5 Beds
  • 7.0 Baths
  • 5,661 SqFt
  • 0.35 Acres

Entertainer's Dream Home On Bay Island, West Of The Trail. Located Just Over The North Bridge On Siesta Key, This Private Sanctuary Showcases Luxury Indoor/outdoor Living, Exceptional Design, Solid Construction And Every Amenity One Could Hope For. Brillian...

Listings have been deleted from all results. Undo Last Delete or View All Deleted Listings

894 Freeling Dr, Sarasota $12,500

  • 4 Beds
  • 3.0 Baths
  • 3,621 SqFt
  • 0.26 Acres

Seasonal Turnkey Furnished 4 Bedrooms, 3 Baths Siesta Key Home. This Home Is Tucked Away On The Secluded End Of Freeling Dr With Full Bay Views. This Home By Land Or See Will Welcome You To The Quiet Island Living. Situated On The Bay With Deep Water Acces...

Listings have been deleted from all results. Undo Last Delete or View All Deleted Listings

707 Norsota Way, Sarasota $18,400

  • 4 Beds
  • 5.0 Baths
  • 2,617 SqFt
  • 0.42 Acres

Vacation Rental Siesta Casa Coram Deo, Luxury Bay Front, 4 Bedroom Home Located In A Private Neighborhood On Siesta Key, Just Minutes From Downtown Sarasota And World Famous Siesta Key Beach. Home Features 100 Ft Of Bay Front W Two 50 Ft Boat Docks, One W L...

Listings have been deleted from all results. Undo Last Delete or View All Deleted Listings

Selling or buying a home in Bay Island soon? Call DWELL Real Estate (941) 822-0708, your Siesta Key, Florida real estate team. Our community of Bay Island REALTORS® team will help you navigate the housing market in Bay Island Siesta Key, FL.

Reviews for Bay Island

0 Based on 0 Ratings
View all Community Ratings & Reviews

Your Rating *

How Do You Know?

Live/Lived Here Just Visited

About You

*Your email address will not be displayed

Your Review


Location of Bay Island


Bay Island Homes in Sarasota

Most of the residential options in the Siesta Key are condominiums. There are approximately 6,500 of them scattered across the island. Single family homes are plentiful with floor plans ranging from 800 square feet of old bungalows to greater than 8,000 square feet of some stunning waterfront Siesta Key homes.

One of the largest real estate developments in the Siesta Key is in Bay Island. It is an island community completely surrounded by water, affording beautiful waterfront home options for potential real estate investors. Houses located in the northern shore of Bay Island enjoy the most stunning views of the Sarasota Bay as well as the city skyline. On top of these amazing backdrops, residents of Siesta Key Bay Island have the Ringling Bridge to admire, which stretches from downtown Sarasota to Bird Key.

Siesta Key Bay Island offers residences along Flamingo Avenue, Hiegel Avenue, Hamilton Avenue, Seagrape Drive, Anglin Drive, and Freeling Drive. Homes in this charming community are some of the best in the Sarasota Florida area, offering a landscape embellished with colorful exotic plants and tropical trees.

Give us a call at 941.822.0708 if we can help you buy or sell a home on Bay Island. Visit our Siesta Key real estate page to view other great places to live in Sarasota, Florida. If Bay Island fits your budget and requirements then you should also explore Bayou LouiseCocoanut BayouGulfmead EstatesRoberts PointSiesta Bayside and Siesta Isles.

Can't find what you're looking for? Let me do the work for you. Fill out the form below and a detailed description of the type of property you're interested in and I'll send you everything currently available.

Your Contact Information

Please provide a valid email address.

Property Information

Moving Details

All listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified through personal inspection by appropriate professionals. Listings displayed on this website may be subject to prior sale or removal from sale; availability of any listing should always be independently verified.

Listing information is provided for consumer personal, non-commercial use, solely to identify potential properties for potential purchase; all other use is strictly prohibited and may violate relevant federal and state law.

Listing data comes from My Florida Regional MLS.

Listing information last updated on July 29th, 2016 at 8:49pm EDT.